PublicSchools Vs Private Schools
PublicSchools Vs Private Schools
Inmodern times, education has become a complex as well as compellingtopic globally. Parents have been involved in search for the bestschool for their siblings. Different aspects have read to the parentsbeing torn between which schools to take their children. Such factorsinclude school quality and accountability as well as the quality ofthe education offered. On the other hand, there has been a differencebetween the children attending any of the types of schools. In themodern times, the distinction between public and private schools isno longer open and straightforward as it was sometime back. This is acomparison paper, between private and public schools in the UnitedStates, with a focus on school vouchers.
Thereis an increased need for education worldwide. However, the number ofstudents in such of education is higher than the number of availableinstitutions. This has in turn led to the establishment of privateschools to supplement the increased need for formal education. Theexistence of both public and private managed schools has tried toreduce the gap between the number of students and the institutionsavailable (Brown, 2012). This has then again prompted the vital levelheaded discussion in correlation between the two types of schoolswith inquiries being raised as to which of the two manifestations ofschool administration is best for the students. Some of the mainfactors that may contribute to parents taking their children toeither of the schools include the schools academic reputation,religious belief and views, school size, location of the school aswell as the cost.
Alot of controversy has been raised over the private schooling andpublic schooling. Much of the controversy has been around the meritsand demerits of each of the different schooling plans (Black, 2013).The choice of which school to take one’s children is majorly leftin the hands of parents. However, before making the decision manyaspects have to be considered. This paper analyzes, compares andcontrasts public and private schools.Researchsuggests that private schools are more focused, dedicated and performbetter than public schools because teachers in private schools arepaid more salaries than their counterparts in public schools, thusmore job satisfaction and motivation, discipline is high amongstudents in private schools than those in public schools and theclass size in private schools is smaller than that in public schoolsenabling a teacher to address individual learning needs of everystudent (Garces, 2009).
Thesisstatement:in the United States, there has been the use of school vouchers,which has over time given offered parents the opportunity to choosefor either a private or public school of their choice using thegovernment offered dollars. School vouchers would result to an issueof equity, and equal opportunity in education in the country.
Thispaper will continuously use terms such as a public school, privateschool, and school vouchers. In a nutshell, a PrivateSchoolis referred as a school that is supported by a private organizationor personnel. These schools are also known as non-governmental,no-state schools or else independent school. One major characteristicis that, the schools under private ownership aren’t as controlledby either local, state or the national governments. On the otherhand, PublicSchoolsin the United States are schools that are supported by public funds,for the education needs of the community, which offers free publiceducation, i.e. primary and secondary schools. Finally, there is theschool vouchers which is a government funded voucher that is givento learners and is redeemable for tuition fee in any school apartfrom a public school, that the beneficially of the voucher couldattend free schools of their choice.
Themost pronounced difference between private and public schools in theUS can be narrowed down to cash. This in turn explains why theprivate schools are however more expensive than public schools. Thisis attributed to the fact that the government funds the publicschools ("Privateversus public").The public schools have the challenge of reduced funds than theyactually require due to their reliance on the government. Theseschools are majorly financed by the government through local, stateand federal taxes as no tuition fee is required. Conversely, privateschools have to look for a source of their funds. They have a varietyof ways to obtain these funds some of which include: educationalcost private allows and gathering pledges from folks, graduatedclass, and other group individuals (Garces, 2009). If the privateschool is connected with a religious gathering, the religiouscommunity may provide a source of revenue.
Thishas led to the low percentage of students in the private schools ofabout 10 % as compared to 90 % of children in the public schools. TheUS department of education, therefore, introduced school vouchersinto the education system. These vouchers offered subsidies intuition fees in private schools for those parents who choose privateschools, but don’t have the financial capability (Garces, 2009).This is so as to offer parents with the opportunity to choose foreither a private or public school of their choice using thegovernment offered dollars. School vouchers majorly try to solve theissue of equal opportunity in education in the country. The schoolvouchers aim at equating the issue of admission between publicschools and private schools. There has been an increased admissioninto public schools than private schools. Public and private schoolshave different admission criteria. Public schools are meant for allstudents and therefore must accept them for admission with no presetcriteria as required of them by the law ("Privateversus public").This has led to the high number of admissions in the public schools.
Privateschools on the other hand, are very selective in regards to admissionof students ("Privateversus public").They are not committed to admitting each child as a result gettingaccepted may include many applications with various meetings,articles, and testing. The private schools also characterize thepersonality or religious affiliations of the ones to admit. Theprivate schools are not required to offer a rationale for theirchoice of accepting or rejecting certain students. This has led tolow numbers of admissions into the private schools. The educationvouchers try to create a balance in terms of admission into either aprivate school or a public one. They reduce the financial limitationof the private schools and therefore enabling them to have a widepool of students to choose from and therefore increase their numberof admissions. This in turn is aimed at increasing the number ofchildren in private institutions.
Thesize of classes differs between the public and private schools. Dueto the reduced number of admissions in private schools, their classesare normally smaller as compared to those in public schools (Kennedy,2015). This leads to a higher quality of education in private schoolsas the teacher student ratio is lower than that in public schoolsfacilitating teacher student communication (Grimes, 1994).More teachers to student interaction mean a more in-depthunderstanding of the material.Education vouchers hence shift this variance in the teacher studentratio in both types of schools as more and more students leave thepublic to private schools decongesting them. The graduation rates inpublic schools are lower than those in private schools (Kennedy,2015). In public schools 62 % to 67 % graduate to continue with theirstudies. This can be attributed to most of the students in publicschools not completing their education. The private schools on theother hand have a higher graduation rate of 90 % to 95 % than that ofpublic schools. On the other hand, there little drop-out rate iswitnessed in the private schools with most of the students reachingtheir graduation. According to NCES, students who attend privateschools are more likely to attend college than those who attendpublic schools.
Topresent an equal opportunity for graduation and progress to higherlearning to all students, education vouchers are given by thegovernment, this is one merit of the school vouchers. Parents andstudents can choose to attend a private school if they qualify withthe high assurances of graduating. This presents an equal opportunityfor graduation and progress to higher learning among all children,regardless of the financial status of the family as the privateeducation is offered to them free of charge. Discipline and order isanother major difference between public and private schools(Brasington, 2014). Order is taken care of contrastingly innon-public schools versus public schools. The teacher in state fundedschools is to some degree confused in light of the fact thatdiscipline has to be administered by due procedure and protectedconstitutional rights of the children (Kennedy, 2015). This has thereasonable impact of making it harder for two teachers to administercorrective actions for minor and significant infractions of theschool`s set of principles and as a result leading to deteriorateddiscipline in public schools.
Inprivate school discipline is administered by the agreement whichstudents and their guardians sign with the school (Kennedy, 2015). Itunmistakably spells out outcomes for what the school considersunsatisfactory conduct. This makes it easier for teachers toadminister corrective actions to students who bleach the signedagreement outlining the expected code of conduct. As a result,students in private schools are more disciplined than those in publicschools. Education vouchers help in reducing this gap as parents aregiven the power to assess the discipline between the public andprivate schools and make a choice that best suits their child. Thequalification of teachers also differs between public and privateschools. All the teachers in private schools are normally stateaccredited (Kennedy, 2015). This is so as to ensure that the teacherhas adequate preparation as needed by the state. It also helps inmaking uniform the quality of teaching. Contrary, teachers in privateschools are not mandated to be accredited. Rather, most of themspecialize in a particular field, making them experts in what theyteach. This translates to better performance in the private schools.Vouchers lead to competition between teachers in private and publicschools to gain recognition improving the overall quality ofeducation.
Thereis a comparable difference between educational program improvement inprivate and state funded schools (Black, 2013). State funded schoolsmust take after state rules that set out particular benchmarks andappraisal systems. In principle, this makes a certain measure ofvalue control. Nonpublic schools can pick whatever educationalprogram and appraisal model they wish. This flexibility to plan theirown particular educational program or evade state administered testscan bring about higher gauges for students. The giving of schoolvouchers creates increased competition between the private and publicschools. This is because it gives an equal opportunity for allchildren, whether from rich or poor backgrounds. The voucher givesparents and students a chance to make a free decision as to whichschool best suits their needs, thus promoting the growth of talentand one’s potential to the maximum.
Schoolson the other hand respond to the vouchers by increasing theiraccountability as well as performance (Brasington, 2014). This is soas to attract students resulting from the competition. As a result ofthe competition, the quality of education is raised in both thepublic and private schools. This has been proved by the improvementin performance of both categories of schools since the inception ofthese vouchers. School vouchers, however relocate public schoolfunding to private schools diverting public resources to the privatesector. This is in the sense that most of the students who benefitfrom these vouchers would have attended public schools. Many peoplealso prefer private schools due to their view that they are moreefficient than public schools. The money which would have otherwisebeen directed to the public school they would have attended isdirected to private schools. This translates to the continued growthand development of private schools at the expense of the publicschools.
Thevouchers, however, have the disadvantage of draining off publicschool children with high potentials (Brasington, 2014). Privateschools are very selective while the public schools accept children,regardless of their gender, religious affiliation, performance, race,disability or religion. The best students, therefore, move to privateschools, leaving public schools with the challenged students. As aresult, the performance of public schools continues to deterioratewhile that of private schools improves. The voucher system is alsounfair to the parents who are in a position to pay for theirchildren. Despite paying fees for their children in private schools,they also pay taxes to run the public schools as well as offer thevouchers. This is like paying fees for three children while they onlyhave one.
Thegiving of school vouchers also leads to the emergence of new privateschools in an attempt to offset the balance and the increased needfor private education at the expense of public schools (Grimes,1994). This in turn increases competition across schools, improvingthe overall quality of education. The system also provides increasedchoices for parents in terms of which school their children attendregardless of private or public without any limitation in terms offinances. The voucher issue also helps parents to take children totheir preferred schools. For example, if the parent wants a schoolwhere prayer is mandatory, he/she can choose without fear offinancial limitation it since the government provides the funds. Thiscan however be a basis of racism and religious conflict.
Childrenin public vs children in private schools
Thedifference between the types of schools in the United States has ledto differ in terms of the schools in each of the school type.However, the introduction of the school voucher by the government,has led to a minimized difference between the children in private andthe ones in public school. One of the major differences betweenchildren attending private and public school is the teacher studentratio. The children in private schools have a better student ratiothan the ones in public schools. This means that, the number ofchildren per teacher in private is less compared to public schools.This in turn has been attributed to improved quality of teacherstudent’s relationship, which also positively affects theperformance of the student. The increased number of students inpublic schools means each teacher has a large number of children tohandle. This in turn means, they may fail to have the neededteacher’s attention.
Someof the benefits associated with public schools include the idea thatin public school teachers has more qualifications in addition,students spend most of their time studying the core subjects.Moreover, the public schools can sponsor more activities compared tothe private schools. Finally, the student populations tend to be morediverse. On the other hand, merits associated with private schoolsinclude the schools as well as the classes are known to be muchsmaller and easy for teachers to manage. Nevertheless, each of theschool types has its associated demerits. On the side of the privateschools, one disadvantage is the cost of education. Private schoolsaren’t funded by the government and in turn have to charge thestudents the tuition fee. This has led to the high cost of educationin private schools compared to the public schools. Unlike thetraditional belief that the quality of education is better in privateschool than the public ones, research has shown that, the quality ofeducation depends on the school, and the available resources.
SchoolVoucher Debate In Relation To Public Vs Private Schools
Theintroduction of the voucher system in the United States educationsystem was a way to reduce the gap that has been between the privateand public schools. The school voucher debate pro. With reference tothe comparison between private and public schools, the introductionof school vouchers in the United States education system has bothmerits and demerits. School vouchers have been associated withseveral positives to the American education system. According to theproposers of the vouchers, it was argued that, a sense of truecompetition between private and public will be coined from the use ofthe school voucher system. This argument has also been presented inthe modern times towards the support of the voucher system. Accordingto Black (2013), the implementation of the system would make itpossible to enroll in private schools which will create a market forboth the public and private schools in the country’s educationsystem. The result for this would mean, public schools will berequired to improve in order to remain competitive.
Anotherpro associated with the implementation of the voucher system is that,its proponents have indicated that, the system would save the statesmoney. On another positive note the school voucher program providedsupport to the poverty stricken children in schools, and in turnbringing along equality with the financially wellbeing children.Accordingto many experts, the educational experiences within a private schoolfar exceed those in a poorly funded public school. However, this hasbeen reduced by the implementation of the voucher system in theUnited States.
Despitethe pros connected to the implementation of the school vouchersystem, the system there are cons for the system. While theproponents of the system have provided different convincing argumentin support of the system, the opposing side highlighted the negativesof the system. One of the most major arguments against SchoolVouchers is the idea of using public money to fund a privateinstitution. This practice was described as fundamental flaw in thevoucher program, and it was questioned why it was used to fund theinstitutions when at the same time the public ones were/areperforming dismally. As the voucher program become more prominent inthe United States, the public schools continued to lose more groundon their competition with the private schools. Another argument isthat, the use of the voucher system in the private institutions wouldturn them to be dependent on the public funding. This may in turnlead to private institutions sacrificing their educational values andthe ideals so as to increase voucher income
Thechoice between whether to take your child to a public or privateschool is multi-dimensional in nature with many factors having to beconsidered. Parents want the best education for their children interms of quality therefore most prefer the private schools, but theissue of fees becomes the limit. The school vouchers have reducedthis discrepancy benefiting hundreds of students. However, the publicschools should be considered as well. This is because all childrencan school in the private schools despite the existence of thesesschool vouchers. The vouchers take funds away from alreadyunderfunded public schools. Efforts should therefore be concentratedon improving the public schools so as to promote favorablecompetition with their private counterparts. Much of the funds shouldbe directed to these public schools rather than private schools so asto improve them. It is the responsibility of the government toprovide quality education for all and more so for the poor who cannotafford private schools. The government should therefore pay attentionto the quality of education in the public sector and concentrate onimproving it rather than using the private sector to improve thequality of education.
Theimplementation of the school voucher system has had both positive andnegative impact to the American education system. To the differencebetween the private and the public schools, the voucher has beenimplemented to bridge the gap between the two. Despite being asuccess to some point, the system has also impacted the quality ofthe education in both the private and public schools. However, thechoice for any parent as to which he/she would take his childrenremains to parent’s disposal, and as seen different factorscontributes to either choice. Moreover, the difference between thepublic and private school isn’t that much abs in turn the choiceof schools depends with parents and children’s desires.
Black,D. W. (2013). Charter Schools, Vouchers, and the Public Good.(English). WakeForest Law Review, 48(2),445-488.
Brasington,D. M., & Hite, D. (2014). School Choice: Supporters andOpponents. ContemporaryEconomic Policy,32(1), 76-92
Brown,D. F. (2012). WhyAmerica`s public schools are the best place for kids: Reality vs.negative perceptions.Lanham, Md: R & L Education.
Garces,J. (2009). The Quality of Private and Public Education: The Case ofChile. Journalof Knowledge Globalization, 2(2),85-109.
Gretaschool, (2015). Privateversus public. Retrieved on 14thApril 2015. From:http://www.greatschools.org/find-a-school/defining-your-ideal/59-private-vs-public-schools.gs?page=all
Grimes,P. W. (1994). Public versus Private Secondary Schools and theProduction of Economic Education. Journalof Economic Education, 25(1),17-30.
JackJennings,(2015) the blog: Proportionof U.S. Students in Private Schools is 10 Percent and Declining.Retrieved on 14thApril 2015. Fromhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/jack-jennings/proportion-of-us-students_b_2950948.html
Parker,R. S., Cook, S., & Pettijohn, C. E. (2007). School ChoiceAttributes: Positioning a Private School. ServicesMarketing Quarterly, 28(4),21-33.
Poliniak,S. (2012). Public Private (and Beyond). TeachingMusic, 19(5),36-41.
RobertKennedy(2015). Abouteducation: Comparisonof Private and Public Schools ALook at the Differences and Similarities. Retrieved on 14thApril 2015. Fromhttp://privateschool.about.com/od/choosingaschool/qt/comparison.htm